Showing posts with label AB Testing. Show all posts
Showing posts with label AB Testing. Show all posts

Monday, May 25, 2009

Small Change with a Huge Impact

Recently I was involved in changing the layout of a website and measuring the impact of that change. We changed the Top navigation on this website and changed the color of a link to Red/Bold. It was a very minor change with respect to the whole website as the Top navigation menu only contributed to less than 5% of users engaging in the website. We wanted to make this change to enhance the Top navigation and entice more clicks on the edited link (Coupons). P.S. We leveraged Google Analytics to measure this change. Below is a screenshot of the previous Top Navigation menu:


After a week, I pulled the ‘Top Content’ report and filtered on the Top menu Coupons link. I was pleasantly shocked to notice the results. There was a 65% increase in User Engagement (Clicks) on the Top navigation Coupons link clearly due to changing the link color to Red. From the context of the website, this page amounts only to a small proportion of traffic but this change has paved the way for similar changes which can be replicated on others pages in the future. Below is a screenshot of the change we made on the Coupons link:


Immediately after noticing this change I sent a tweet in excitement: ‘Wow! Top menu navigation link text change resulted in over 60% increase in user clicks. Changed the font of the link to Red/Bold #ga #wa’. Surprisingly, I got a response from a Twitter user: ‘So funny. We also changed the nationalgeographic.com top nav to red/bold in Dec 07 for commerce promo. It stuck.’ The user mentioned that Nationalgeographic also made a similar change back on 2007 and they too noticed an increase in clicks on the button. Isn’t it coincidental?

Going forward we plan to replicate the same exercise on the Side menu. We will also be performing AB Tests on the Top navigation menu and compare it with newer menus. P.S. It is always a good practice to add a query string parameter in the URL. E.g. Add ‘menu=top’ (http://www.seattleindian.com/seattle/indian-restaurant-coupons.asp?menu=top) to distinguish this URL as a Top navigation link.

Hope you like this article. Please comment and let me know if you’ve done similar exercises and noticed a considerable impact.

Sunday, March 23, 2008

AB/Multivariate/Segmentation Testing– Choosing the best Page/Combination/Segment

Web Analytics is not just pulling numbers from the Web Analytics tools and reporting numbers, it is much more than that. As an Analyst, your task is to report the numbers in a presentable and descriptive manner with analysis but also give suggestions on how to continuously improve the website in terms of appeal and ease of use. This article will touch base on the 3 major website conversion testing methods: AB Testing, Multivariate Testing and Segmentation Testing.

AB Testing or Bucket Test as you might call it is a way to test 2 variations of a page in order to determine which page is more successful in terms of pulling people towards a website goal. We split traffic on each page based on a defined proportion (50/50, 90/10). Usually the first step where there are most chances of convincing a user to buy something is the homepage as this is the page that defines a website in terms of visual appeal, product listing, ease of navigation, color scheme and even text. These things go a long way in generating a sense of trust in the users. For e.g. we have a website whose business model is selling books and there are 2 AB Test pages with the first page being the Control (original) having a discount offer banner on the top and the second page doesn’t have any discount offer banner but a slideshow listing the top selling books. We will then put tracking codes on both these pages and identify each page with a unique identifier in order to measure each page’s success. This success is usually measured in terms of the Conversion ratio which can be measured as: Visitors on the Conversion page/Visitors on the Test/Home Page. Some tools that can help you achieve AB Testing are Google Website Optimizer, Verster, SiteSpect and SplitAnalyzer. Below is a screenshot depicting a typical AB test report.


The second and the most efficient method to optimize your page is known as a Multivariate Testing. In this method, we don’t use multiple pages to determine a higher conversion rate but we test the same page by changing the elements around. For e.g. we can test headlines, colors, buttons and images on the same page by correlating each element with each other to find the best possible combination/element. The method used to achieve this is known as the Taguchi Method. This method takes into consideration the sample size and how long a test should run in order to have a clear winner. Google Website Optimizer uses this method to measure a multivariate test. This tool lets you view the various combinations and elements separately and then based on the Taguchi method decides the winner. All you need to do is add a tracking code on to your page and Google Website Optimizer will then split the traffic equally on each element separately. Please look at the below screenshot to understand how Google Website Optimizer measures a multivariate test. Some other tools that can help you achieve multivariate Testing are Google Website Optimizer, Optimost, Memetrics, Verster, Maxymiser and Omniture Test&Target.


Another form of testing which can be used to target specific segments like country, keywords, referring domains and direct traffic is known as Segmentation. In this we split the traffic based on a defined segment and then track the success factor/behavior pattern of each segment. This is the first step to achieve Behavioral Targeting which is in itself a very powerful way to understand user patterns. Please look at the below mockup segmentation test report screenshot.
Again the best KPI to measure the success is the Conversion rate. Some tools that can help you achieve Segmentation are Google Analytics (Free), Kefta and Maxymiser.